Speed Debate Robert Seith | CWK Network
 
 
As long as you understand it’s not a public speaking contest the academic value of it is that they’re thinking very quickly but they’re also listening very critically and most of us do not listen. And these kids have a concentration level that we would admire in an education setting that we don’t have.

- Melissa Wade, Emory National Debate Institute... explaining the form of policy debate where the opening arguments are spoken so quickly... the casual listening can barely make out more than a few words.

  Related Information What Parents Need To Know Resources

It’s fast…

It’s frantic…

It’s the new face of debate…

The teenagers speak so fast, the untrained listener may not be able to catch more than a few words… but believe it or not, the judges hear it all.

And the debaters use that to their advantage…

“They’ve got so much research they’ve done that they want to pack that into the record of the debate,” explains Melissa Wade, a chief organizer of a Nationwide competition that takes place each year at Emory University, “And so they have a very specialized set of judges, it’s not audience debate.”

The end result, 8-minute opening arguments that are fast, almost comically fast.

“A lot of them are bad imitations of good debaters who can do this,” explains Wade, “But the speed is sort of a goal in this particular activity, it’s valued.”

And many of these kids, who once thought of debate as stodgy and dull, love the intensity… the challenge.

“It’s just awesome it’s just this adrenaline rush it’s like taking six SAT’s in a day,” says 14-year-old Lena Garrett.

“It’s like a sport in a way. It’s more of a mental sport where you have to outwit the other teams,” adds Robin Ayers, also 14.

A recent study by the National Association of Urban Debate Leagues found that getting a child involved in debate raises their reading scores by 25-percent, on average.

“I developed all these research techniques and I was just really motivated and passionate about my work and when I got into 8 th grade I was just on fire,” says Garrett.

So, experts say, if this gets more kids interested in debate all the better.

“It’s a game and it’s competition,” says Wade, “Go try it out, see what you think.”

By Larry Eldridge
CWK Network, Inc.

In the past, competitive debate was mostly associated with students who attended private schools and came from affluent backgrounds. But the argumentative practice is now gaining popularity with students all across the United States, even those who attend inner-city schools. In fact, the National Association of Urban Debate Leagues (NAUDL) says approximately 3,000 students take part in its nationwide program.

So why are more students choosing to exercise their minds by joining high school debate teams? According to a study conducted by Gary Alan Fine, author of Gifted Tongues: High School Debate and Adolescent Culture, the reasons for teens’ involvement in debate fall into three categories:

  • Strategic Involvement – Many students associate debate with the worlds of politics and law, and some who desire to follow these career paths say joining a debate team is a “logical choice.” Others join in an attempt to “beef up” their transcripts before applying to college.
  • Fun Experience – The number of students who join because “I always liked to argue” is considerable. These students find competitive debate both challenging and conducive to camaraderie.
  • Network Recruitment – Many students join a debate team because their friends are members. Others say that their parents, siblings or teachers whom they admire often influence their decision to try competitive debating.
 
By Larry Eldridge
CWK Network, Inc.

The NAUDL says that because students involved in debate regularly engage in writing, information analysis, and in-depth library and Internet research, they often receive higher grades than non-debaters in high school and are more likely to continue on to post-secondary education. A recent study published by the National Communication Association lends further evidence to debate’s educational benefits. The study’s findings showed students who participated in organized debate for at least one year improved their critical thinking skills by 44 percent. If you want to encourage your teen to join a debate team, the Puget Sound Speech and Debate Association suggests informing him or her of these potential benefits of participation. Debating …

  • Offers preparation for leadership.
  • Provides for investigation and intensive analysis of significant contemporary problems.
  • Develops proficiency in critical thinking.
  • Emphasizes quality instruction.
  • Encourages student scholarship.
  • Develops the ability to make prompt, analytical responses.
  • Develops critical listening skills.
  • Develops proficiency in writing.
  • Encourages mature judgment.
  • Develops courage.
  • Encourages effective speech composition and delivery.
  • Develops social maturity.
  • Develops multicultural sensitivities.
  • Develops computer competencies.

Although the popularity of debate is rising, many schools do not have a debate program in place. The National PTA encourages parents to approach their children’s school administrators with concerns about student programs or the lack thereof. If your child’s school cannot provide a forum for debate, you can find information for student involvement in national or state high school debate programs by contacting the UDL or the National Forensic League.

 
National Association of Urban Debate Leagues
Gifted Tongues: High School Debate and Adolescent Culture
National Communication Association
Puget Sound Speech and Debate Association
 
(404) 459-8081 • info@cwknetwork.comCWK Network, Inc. ©2008 • This site is best viewed at 800x600 or above.